PSA/DNA Autograph Authenticating Gone Wrong

PSA/DNA Autograph Authenticating Gone Wrong

The voice of many autograph collectors is  “stay away from PSA/DNA". The reason has been and still is, they can't get it right. Many times items they passed as genuine, readers here were able to see with their own eyes how badly the “experts” at PSA/DNA got it very wrong. Here’s one more shot where you can see the poor quality of work by what is created by the fabricated “experts” at PSA/DNA.

See below, what PSA/DNA claims is 5  genuine signatures of George Lucas.

 

31308197485?profile=RESIZE_710x

31308197276?profile=RESIZE_710x31308313280?profile=RESIZE_710x

 

31308318694?profile=RESIZE_710x

 

 31308319457?profile=RESIZE_710x

It’s near impossible to believe the so-called experts at PSA/DNA believe the above 5 signatures are all by the same hand. This is just one of many reasons why over 70 professional autograph dealers don’t have to issue a refund based on any “opinion” issued by PSA/DNA.

A question could be why they come to the conclusion that these 5 examples and more are all signed by the same hand? 

Was it for a friend?  Are the things they are offering their own?  Examples of these can be found in a 1st grade class room amongst say 27 students.  Ask them all to quickly draw a scribble and cursive.   This could possibly be believing fabricated stories from people who said they got them from people they like or in person without ever verifying anything!  It's a total scam.

Another way to understand a scam is say you have a Ferrari and I have a beat up pickup truck.  We both drive to the same car wash.  They tell me my beat up pick up truck will cost $5 to run through the car wash.  Then it's you're turn.  Oh, A Ferrari they say, that will be $100.  They all do this.  If it's a Babe Ruth signature it will cost you $500 plus for their opinion (whose?) backed by nothing.  But if it's Anna Maria Alberghetti's signature it's only $7.  How is that fair when Ruth has 8 letters in his signature and Alberghetti's has 18 letters in her signature.  Simply based off the value.  So they want to own part of your collection by investing themselves into it for a higher cost for a higher dollar item. Of course they will determine the value of your item?  What business or store does that in the real world?  They do!

One of many more dumb examples of this incompetence.  Go on eBay and type in Al Pacino signed photograph PSA/DNA.  Find  5 PSA'd Al Pacino's.  How did they authenticate each of these?  How do they resemble one another at all?  It's magic. 

Some of the authenticators who pretend they are legit trash some dealers by intentionally failing their autographs.   

 A long established dealer sent in a Carl Yastrzemskim signed  item and submitted it to PSA/DNA. It was returned as being a failure  stating the Carl Yratrzemski was fake.  What they failed to notice was it had a Carl Yastrzemski hologram (his own authentication sticker) affixed. 

Before Stan Lee died both PSA and Grad with JSA passed 5,000 signed Marvel Comic Books that were horrible forgeries and simply because the forger also forged his (Stan Lee) authentication hologram.  It's a mess.

A collector recently submitted a Patrick Henry document he was looking at buying for $20,000.  it was already authenticated by PSA & JSA.  The seller was John Reznikoff, the guy who brags about being the only authenticator for both PSA & JSA.  

I looked through  PADA’s  Patrick Henry file.  And guess what I found?


The same exact document was first sold in 1972.  It was sold by Charles Hamilton, the top authenticator of his time who many say was the best ever.    It sold for $200.  Why?  Because according to Charles Hamilton it wasn't signed by Patrick Henry at all.  But instead his son. 

When Patrick Henry became a founding father during the revolutionary war, he turned his silversmith business over to his son to run while he was warning the other founding fathers that the British were coming on horseback.  His son was also named Patrick Henry and although their names were the same, they signed slightly differently.  What's ironic is what happened to the original Hamilton COA?  Amazingly. it disappeared because someone wanted to make $20,000 not $100 or so.  The collector saved $20k.

 

 Recommendation.  Invest $100.00 or so by purchasing some modern autograph reference books. A good start would be books authored by a genuine autograph expert Ron Keurajian.  He is an award winning author of books with titles:   Baseball Hall of Fame Autographs, A Reference Guide  and  Collecting Historical Autographs, What to Buy, What to Pay, and How to Spot Fakes.

 

★
★
★
★
★
Votes: 0
E-mail me when people leave their comments –

You need to be a member of Autograph Planet to add comments!

Join Autograph Planet